Cost of acquisition for shares bought before February 2018

For listed shares and equity funds bought before 1st Feb 2018, your cost for tax can be the price on 31st Jan 2018, not what you paid.

Team Quicko

· Updated

Share
Share

TL;DR

Gains on listed shares and equity funds up to 31st Jan 2018 are protected from tax. Your cost is the higher of what you paid and the lower of the 31st Jan 2018 value and your sale price. Only the rise after that date is taxed.

Gains on listed shares and equity funds up to 31st Jan 2018 are protected from tax. Your cost is the higher of what you paid and the lower of the 31st Jan 2018 value and your sale price. Only the rise after that date is taxed.

Why 31st January 2018 matters

Until 31st Mar 2018, long-term gains on listed shares and equity mutual funds were exempt from tax. The Budget presented on 1st Feb 2018 brought them back into tax from 1st Apr 2018.

People who already held shares had bought them expecting no tax on the gain. So the law protected every rupee of gain built up until 31st Jan 2018, the day before the Budget. This protection is commonly called the grandfathering rule: an old rule keeps applying to what existed before the change.

Who the rule applies to

You can use it when all of these are true:

  • The asset is a listed equity share, a unit of an equity-oriented mutual fund or a unit of a business trust.

  • You acquired it before 1st Feb 2018.

  • You sell it as a long-term asset on which securities transaction tax (STT) is paid. For shares, STT must generally have been paid on the purchase as well.

It applies however many years later you sell. Shares bought in 2015 and sold in Tax Year 2026-27 still get it.

How the cost is worked out

Your cost of acquisition is not always what you paid. It is found in two steps:

  1. Take the lower of the fair market value on 31st Jan 2018 and your sale price.

  2. Take the higher of that figure and your actual purchase price.

Cost = Higher of (actual cost) and (lower of fair market value on 31st Jan 2018 and sale value)

Applies to long-term listed shares and equity fund units acquired before 1st Feb 2018.

Formula

Cost = Higher of (actual cost) and (lower of fair market value on 31st Jan 2018 and sale value)

Applies to long-term listed shares and equity fund units acquired before 1st Feb 2018.

Formula

Cost = Higher of (actual cost) and (lower of fair market value on 31st Jan 2018 and sale value)

Applies to long-term listed shares and equity fund units acquired before 1st Feb 2018.

Formula

What fair market value means here

Fair market value (FMV) is the price the asset would fetch in the open market on a given day. For this rule it is fixed by the law:

  • Listed shares and listed units: the highest price quoted on a recognised stock exchange on 31st Jan 2018. If it did not trade that day, the highest price on the last day it traded before that.

  • Mutual fund units not listed on an exchange: the net asset value (NAV) on 31st Jan 2018.

For shares that were not listed on 31st Jan 2018 but are listed when you sell, the law uses an indexed cost instead.

Three worked cases

Example

Example

Farhan bought 100 shares at ₹200 in 2016.

The highest price on 31st Jan 2018 was ₹500.

  • Sells at ₹800: lower of ₹500 and ₹800 is ₹500, higher of ₹200 and ₹500 is ₹500. Gain: (₹800 − ₹500) × 100 = ₹30,000

  • Sells at ₹400: lower of ₹500 and ₹400 is ₹400, higher of ₹200 and ₹400 is ₹400. Gain: Nil

  • Sells at ₹150: lower of ₹500 and ₹150 is ₹150, higher of ₹200 and ₹150 is ₹200. Loss: (₹200 − ₹150) × 100 = ₹5,000

In the first case, the ₹300 a share that Farhan gained before 31st Jan 2018 is not taxed.

What the rule cannot do

The second case above shows the limit. Farhan sold at ₹400, below the 31st Jan 2018 price of ₹500. He does not get to claim a loss of ₹100 a share, because he bought at ₹200 and made real money.

The rule is built so that:

  • A gain made before 31st Jan 2018 is never taxed.

  • A fall after 31st Jan 2018 never becomes a loss, unless you sold below your actual purchase price.

Bonus shares you received before 1st Feb 2018 also use the 31st Jan 2018 value in the same way.

Remember

Where to find the 31st January 2018 price

You don't have to search old price lists. Your broker's tax profit and loss statement shows the 31st Jan 2018 value for each share bought before that date and applies the rule for you. Mutual fund capital gains statements do the same with the NAV.

Check two things: that the purchase date shown is before 1st Feb 2018, and that the cost used is not lower than what you paid.

Key takeaways

The rule covers listed shares and equity fund units bought before 1st Feb 2018.

You never use a cost lower than what you actually paid.

The rule can reduce a gain to zero, but it cannot create a loss.

General information, not tax advice. Rules change, so check with a CA before you act.